Why did the Guardian take down the sociologist Brian Taylor's online obituary?

Why did the Guardian take down the sociologist Brian Taylor's online obituary?

Why did the Guardian take down an online obituary to the sociologist Brian Taylor, without telling readers?

In November 2016, the Guardian published a celebratory obituary, online, of the Sussex University sociologist Brian Taylor, who had died aged 66. In May 2017 the newspaper took it down, but did not explain the decision to readers. They were left in the dark.

My intervention in February 2017 led to the decision to delete the obituary. I did not ask for deletion. I asked the paper to add important information that was missing. Censorship was not a satisfactory response to the problem with the obituary. 

During the 1970s and 1980s, Brian Taylor played a major part in the attempt to decriminalise sexual relations between adults and minors, in other words legalising child sexual abuse. He published academic research on the subject of paedophilia, but did not disclose his membership of the Paedophile Information Exchange (PIE) lobbying group. In articles such as ‘Motives for a guilt free pederasty’ (1977), plus in his editorship, and lengthy introduction to, Perspectives on Paedophilia (1982), Taylor attempted to ‘normalise’ child-adult sexual contact. 

Three more contributors to Perspectives on Paedophilia were also undeclared PIE members. They were Dr Morris Fraser (previously and subsequently convicted of child abuse), Peter Righton (subsequently convicted), and Professor Ken Plummer of Essex University. The latter said in 2014 that he joined PIE for purposes of ethnographic research. He appeared to regret his former interest in the subject. This saga is discussed in detail in Professor David Pilgrim’s excellent, Child sexual abuse: Moral panic or state of denial? (Routledge, 2018). Spinwatch published two reports on Morris Fraser, in 2016 and 2017.

To return to Brian Taylor, his paedophile interest went beyond academic writing. As ‘Humphrey Barton’, he was PIE’s Research Director. Taylor/‘Barton’ edited the PIE magazine, Magpie. It published sexualised images of children and also contact-advertisements for men who wished to meet children for an illegal purpose, sexual abuse. 

A passage in a 1976 article by ‘Barton’ for a paedophile journal, Kalos (Vol. 1, No. 1) was almost identical to one in Taylor’s Perspectives on Paedophilia introduction. ‘Barton’ and Taylor lived simultaneously in Belfast in 1976, where Taylor lectured in Queen’s University’s Social Studies department. Understanding Paedophilia (June-July 1976) informed readers that ‘Barton’ was a sociology lecturer in a British university. Later in 1976 (Aug-Sept) it congratulated ‘Barton’ for giving ‘a highly successful paper on paedophilia’ at a sociology conference in Manchester, at which a ‘B. Taylor’ spoke on ‘Aspects of sexual deviance: Paedophilia’.

The evidence appears irrefutable, that  ‘Barton’ and Taylor were the same person (for more detail, see the attached PDF).

The Guardian obituary contained none of this information. Writing and agitating on paedophilia constituted for many years a major part of Brian Taylor’s research output, of his political and also (presumably) of his personal life. 

It was not possible for readers to discern Taylor’s research interest from the following obituary passage,

[Taylor’s] teaching career began with a year at Queen’s University, Belfast, before his move to Sussex in 1977. There he initially focused on aspects of deviance and religion but his main interest was literature, especially Ulster novelists of the early 20th century.

As Perspectives on Paedophilia was published in 1982, Taylor’s interest in ‘deviance’ was not left behind in Belfast. Furthermore, his literary research linked in with Taylor’s pre-existing concerns. The obituary mentioned that Taylor ‘wrote the definitive biography of the Irish author Forrest Reid’, but not that Reid was a paedophile whose fiction was devoted to paedophile themes. The obituary appreciation presented instead Taylor’s ‘criticism of British compromises with the IRA in Northern Ireland’. 

An obituary appreciation that made no reference to important aspects of Taylor’s life was misleading.

Taylor vacated his academic post in the mid-1990s, aged 45 or so, for as yet unexplained reasons. The obituary mentioned Taylor departing Sussex in 2001 for retirement in France, but not precisely when he ceased full-time teaching in the University of Sussex. 

During the mid-1990s media focus on criminal aspects of paedophilia increased. In June 1994 the BBC broadcast an Inside Story exposé of the paedophile criminal and retired director of the National Children’s Bureau, Peter Righton. The programme featured also the recently imprisoned (in 2014) teacher and one-time PIE treasurer Charles Napier, and the child psychiatrist Dr Morris Fraser, who finally vacated the medical register in 1995. In 1981, as supposed professional childcare experts, Righton conspired with Fraser to have Napier’s teaching ban rescinded. Fraser and Napier, who were first convicted of child sexual abuse in 1972, later conspired together to abuse boys. 

Perspectives on Paedophilia featured on the BBC programme. It was mentioned also in a Guardian article on Righton the same day, 1 June 1994. It is not known what media or official contact, if any, was made with Taylor and/or his employer at that time. At the very least, perhaps it was anticipated that attention on Taylor was about to increase. That is speculation. 

I put it to the Guardian that I was in a position to supply the missing information. The newspaper decided to do nothing and to leave the obituary as was. The author of the piece, David Harrison, a colleague and friend of Taylor’s since 1977, responded to the Guardian after it notified him of my concerns. He kindly allowed the paper to share his response with me. Harrison said he was not aware of Taylor’s membership of PIE. He added that the obituary did not mention Taylor’s editorship of Perspectives on Paedophilia, because the book received ‘so much hostility’. That seemed to me a reason to mention the work. 

After some further correspondence, I wrote to the Guardian Readers’ Editor, Paul Chadwick. He responded as follows on 1 May 2017:

'As requested, I have looked into this matter.

In all the circumstances, I believe the appropriate course is for the article to be taken down from the Guardian website and I will make arrangements accordingly.'

I responded that an addendum would have been preferable. I asked if it was Chadwick’s intention to tell the readers he represented what had happened to the obituary. Had that information been published it would have been acceptable, if not preferable. I received no reply. 

Readers are served by information, rather than by its secret withdrawal. Successful censorship was possible because the obituary was published online. Had it been in the newspaper, it could not have been deleted as though it never existed. Paul Chadwick’s solution, censoring the obituary seemed, a tad, unethical, which brings us here.

To set the record accurately on the removal of Brian Taylor’s obituary, Spinwatch is publishing this explanation and also correspondence with Paul Chadwick (download pdf attachment below), that contains a copy of my suggested short addendum. It contains also the Brian Taylor obituary the Guardian subsequently deleted and the I June 1994 Guardian article on Peter Righton.

  • Brian Taylor sociologist
  • Guardian obituary
  • Perspectives on Paedophilia
  • Blogs
  • Peter Righton
  • Morris Fraser

    Dear friends of this aggregator

    • Yes, I intentionally removed Newsbud from the aggregator on Mar 22.
    • Newsbud did not block the aggregator, although their editor blocked me on twitter after a comment I made to her
    • As far as I know, the only site that blocks this aggregator is Global Research. I have no idea why!!
    • Please stop recommending Newsbud and Global Research to be added to the aggregator.

    Support this site

    News Sources

    Source Items
    WWI Hidden History 50
    Grayzone Project 162
    Pass Blue 205
    Dilyana Gaytandzhieva 14
    John Pilger 416
    The Real News 367
    Scrutinised Minds 29
    Need To Know News 2568
    FEE 4574
    Marine Le Pen 380
    Francois Asselineau 25
    Opassande 53
    HAX on 5July 220
    Henrik Alexandersson 904
    Mohamed Omar 370
    Professors Blog 10
    Arg Blatte Talar 40
    Angry Foreigner 18
    Fritte Fritzson 12
    Teologiska rummet 32
    Filosofiska rummet 106
    Vetenskapsradion Historia 152
    Snedtänkt (Kalle Lind) 216
    Les Crises 2787
    Richard Falk 166
    Ian Sinclair 107
    SpinWatch 61
    Counter Currents 9427
    Kafila 470
    Gail Malone 38
    Transnational Foundation 221
    Rick Falkvinge 95
    The Duran 9712
    Vanessa Beeley 121
    Nina Kouprianova 9
    MintPress 5626
    Paul Craig Roberts 1806
    News Junkie Post 58
    Nomi Prins 27
    Kurt Nimmo 191
    Strategic Culture 4748
    Sir Ken Robinson 24
    Stephan Kinsella 97
    Liberty Blitzkrieg 851
    Sami Bedouin 64
    Consortium News 2666
    21 Century Wire 3530
    Burning Blogger 324
    Stephen Gowans 88
    David D. Friedman 152
    Anarchist Standard 16
    The BRICS Post 1513
    Tom Dispatch 523
    Levant Report 18
    The Saker 4299
    The Barnes Review 526
    John Friend 471
    Psyche Truth 159
    Jonathan Cook 145
    New Eastern Outlook 3963
    School Sucks Project 1775
    Giza Death Star 1910
    Andrew Gavin Marshall 15
    Red Ice Radio 612
    GMWatch 2295
    Robert Faurisson 150
    Espionage History Archive 34
    Jay's Analysis 961
    Le 4ème singe 90
    Jacob Cohen 207
    Agora Vox 15450
    Cercle Des Volontaires 436
    Panamza 2184
    Fairewinds 117
    Project Censored 945
    Spy Culture 527
    Conspiracy Archive 76
    Crystal Clark 11
    Timothy Kelly 567
    PINAC 1482
    The Conscious Resistance 834
    Independent Science News 80
    The Anti Media 6661
    Positive News 820
    Brandon Martinez 30
    Steven Chovanec 61
    Lionel 292
    The Mind renewed 441
    Natural Society 2619
    Yanis Varoufakis 999
    Tragedy & Hope 122
    Dr. Tim Ball 114
    Web of Debt 145
    Porkins Policy Review 421
    Conspiracy Watch 174
    Eva Bartlett 596
    Libyan War Truth 335
    DeadLine Live 1913
    Kevin Ryan 63
    BSNEWS 2080
    Aaron Franz 233
    Traces of Reality 166
    Revelations Radio News 121
    Dr. Bruce Levine 145
    Peter B Collins 1560
    Faux Capitalism 205
    Dissident Voice 10756
    Climate Audit 224
    Donna Laframboise 437
    Judith Curry 1129
    Geneva Business Insider 40
    Media Monarchy 2382
    Syria Report 78
    Human Rights Investigation 91
    Intifada (Voice of Palestine) 1685
    Down With Tyranny 11888
    Laura Wells Solutions 44
    Video Rebel's Blog 435
    Revisionist Review 485
    Aletho News 20426
    ضد العولمة 27
    Penny for your thoughts 3008
    Northerntruthseeker 2379
    كساريات 37
    Color Revolutions and Geopolitics 27
    Stop Nato 4712 Blog 3070 Original Content 6939
    Corbett Report 2357
    Stop Imperialism 491
    Land Destroyer 1198
    Webster Tarpley Website 1103

    Compiled Feeds

    Public Lists

    Title Visibility
    Funny Public