On Tuesday night, the Trump circus found its way to Hershey, Pennsylvania, where Pennsylvania's 9th, 10th, and 11th congressional districts meet. Hershey is in the 10th. Trump won all three districts and all three are held by Republicans in Congress, but the 10th is the least solidly Republican and I suspect Rep. Scott Perry was worried that Trump was showing up in his district, which Trump only won with 52.3% in 2016. According to the latest Morning Consult numbers, Trump's approval statewide has decreased by 17 points since he was inaugurated and now stands at 45% approve, 52% disapprove-- 7 points underwater.Hershey is in Dauphin County, which Trump lost in 2016. Hillary beat him narrowly, 64,287 (49.4%) to 60,620 (46.6%). Last year Dauphin County went strongly for both Senator Bob Casey and Governor Tom Wolf, both Democrats. Dauphin in the biggest part of PA-10 and it went decisively against Perry and for Democrat George Scott (D+8). Did Trump's deranged stand up routine do Republicans in the area any good?Wednesday morning, Aaron Rupar wrote that the disgusting rally revealed a presidency off the rails. The performance, he wrote, "highlighted many of the reasons people feel that the country will struggle to withstand another year of this-- even in the likely event that the Senate doesn’t end up removing him from office. Over the course of a more than 90-minute delivery, Trump pushed conspiracy theories and blatant lies, trashed law enforcement officials that aren’t blindly loyal to him, exhibited thuggish tendencies toward protesters, made misogynistic remarks, and demonstrated that he fundamentally misunderstands the Constitution. It was one of his most troubling performances in recent memory and served as a stark illustration of just how ugly Trump’s reelection campaign will be."
Trump has access to information and briefings from some of the world’s top intelligence professionals. And yet he can’t seem to stop himself from spreading rumor and innuendo in an effort to demean his political foes.During a portion of his speech on Tuesday in which he demeaned both the FBI rank-and-file and bureau leadership, Trump out of nowhere suggested, without evidence, that former FBI agent Lisa Page took out a restraining order against former FBI agent Peter Strzok. Strzok and Page became become right-wing punching bags and the subject of conspiracy theories after it was revealed that while in the course of having an affair with eachother during their FBI tenures, the two shared personal text messages in which they expressed anti-Trump opinions.“Did I hear he needed a restraining order after this whole thing, from Lisa? That’s what I heard. I don’t know if it’s true,” Trump said.Page herself later tweeted that Trump’s claim is “a lie,” adding, “Nothing like this ever happened.It obviously doesn’t take much to debunk a claim of this sort. But the point is that the president is shameless enough to push them in the first place. Fact-checks and logical reasoning have a hard time dealing with Trump’s firehose of nonsense.Trump’s comments about Strzok and Page were part of his broader attack on the FBI. Hours after Trump lashed out at FBI Director Christopher Wray for telling the truth about an Inspector General report that concluded the origins of the bureau’s Russia investigation weren’t tainted by political bias, Trump took aim at his hand-picked director once again.“You have great people in the FBI, but not in leadership. You have not good people in leadership,” Trump said.Later, while lamenting how the FBI “destroyed the lives of people” who were associated with his campaign-- a comment alluding apparently to people like Paul Manafort and Roger Stone-- Trump referred to FBI agents as “scum.”“Their lives have been destroyed by scum, ok? By scum,” Trump said, before hyping a forthcoming report by US Attorney John Durham that apparently will be harsher on the FBI than the just-released IG report.Not only were these comments ugly, but they demonstrate how Trump demands total personal loyalty from law enforcement agencies that in theory are supposed to operate independently of partisan politics. But to Trump, if the FBI director speaks the truth and refuses to validate conspiracy theories about anti-Trump bias in the FBI, then he’s not the right person for the job. If bureau brass goes after his associates, they’re “scum.” If the Inspector General was appointed by Barack Obama, then his work is inherently suspect.Trump has been accused of sexual misconduct by more than 20 women, and yet during his speech in Hershey he tried to politicize sex crimes committed by undocumented immigrants. He gloated about how his use of a racial slur hurt Sen. Elizabeth Warren’s poll numbers-- “she opened that fresh mouth of hers and it stopped,” he said-- and at another point, told a story in which he referred to Warren’s marriage as “a phony, disgusting deal.”When his speech was disrupted by a protester, Trump lamented that security wasn’t rougher with her, saying, “that particular guy wanted to be so politically correct. Ahhh! Ahhh! We don’t want to be political correct!”Later, Trump referred to House Intelligence Committee Chair Adam Schiff as a “crooked bastard” and seemed to barely catch himself from wishing physical harm upon him.But perhaps even more ominously, Trump warned of doomsday if he doesn’t win reelection next year.“At stake in our present battle is the survival of the American nation itself. We will destroy our country if these people get in,” Trump said.When he wasn’t warning of the apocalypse if he doesn’t win a second term, Trump teased shredding the Constitution by serving as many as 29 years in office.Though Trump took pains to point out that he’s kidding, this particular “joke” has become such a staple of his speeches that one can’t help but wonder.Less than a week after video of Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau and European leaders mocking him at a NATO summit went viral, Trump claimed, absurdly, that “this country is so respected. And we were not respected four years ago. We were laughed at.” And just hours after a federal judge blocked his plan to spend billions of military dollars on his border wall, Trump said “we’re building it and it’s fine and we have the military money coming in from the military. Believe me... we started winning in court.”Trump described the whistleblower complaint that initially sounded the alarm about his dealings with Ukraine as incorrect, despite the fact that every key allegation in it has been corroborated. As his speech wound down, Trump proclaimed “we support, protect, and defend the Constitution of the United States.” But earlier in the speech he described Democrats’ efforts to follow the impeachment process as specified in that very same Constitution as an attempt to “overthrow our democracy.”Many more examples of ugliness from just Trump’s speech in Hershey could be cited. He sensationalized crimes committed by undocumented immigrants in gory detail-- “last summer at least 19 illegal aliens were charged in connection with grizzly homicides, including hacking victims to death and ripping out, in two cases, their hearts,” he said-- and made a variety of false accusations against Democrats, including that they want “to get rid of religion” and support infanticide. He also expressed his usual tragicomical level of ignorance about how wind energy works.The dark spectacle doesn’t necessarily bolster Democrats’ impeachment case, but it does illustrate what the stakes are-- not only of a possible impeachment trial, but of the 2020 campaign. Watching Trump deliver such a nakedly authoritarian speech behind the presidential seal made it hard to shake the thought that the election that really mattered was 2016.
I've never been to Hershey but while I was at Sire Records and then Reprise, we had a band on the labels I really liked, the Ocean Blue. The band members were all from there. Steve Lau, who wrote one of the band's most popular songs and played keyboards and sax (below) is living in a different part of Pennsylvania now. This morning, he told me that he "grew up going to a mega church in Hershey in the 80’s. Seeing the interviews of Trump supporters waiting in line for his rally Tuesday kind of took me back in a way. Some of these Trump supporters' investment in narratives runs so deep that they simply won’t let facts get in their way. When I was growing up and decided to be honest with my bandmates, who were also my best friends, about my being gay, they said 'we can’t accept your lifestyle.' These guys were so dug in and invested in their 'christian' storyline that they were unable to accept the truth about their best friend (and punished me accordingly). More than anything, the obliteration of truth as a concept is what continues to scare me the most about people."