Study: GM Crops, Touted For Pest Resistance, Rapidly Breed Resistant Pests

A new study, funded by the U.S. government and published in the journal Nature Biotechnology, has added to the evidence that pest resistance to genetically modified (GM) crops has been rising dramatically for decades. The study, which examines 20 years of data, focused on a specific class of GM crops that have been bioengineered to produce insect-killing proteins naturally produced by the Bacillus thuringiensis (Bt) bacterium. The proteins, though often used on non-industrial farms as a form of organic pest control, were found to facilitate particularly rapid pest resistance when produced within GM crops.

In terms of its more specific findings, the researchers found that, out of 36 cases, 16 showed problematic instances of pest resistance that dramatically reduced the crop’s efficacy within five years of the crop’s introduction. The study also found that incidence of such cases has jumped in recent years, as only three such cases had been identified in 2005. Seventeen cases did not show pest resistance to Bt crops and three others were flagged as showing early warnings of resistance, meaning that pest resistance was statistically significant but had yet to dramatically affect crop yield.

The study also noted that pest resistance to Bt crops has begun evolving at a faster rate in recent years, as resistance to previously introduced strains breeds cross-resistance to other Bt proteins introduced in subsequent GM Bt crops.

In addition, the study – whose authors are supportive of GM crops overall – touted the effectiveness of the “high-dose/refuge strategy,” in which GM crops producing high doses of Bt proteins are interspersed among “abundant refuges” that consist of non-GM plants. This practice was found to dramatically slow the development of pest resistance. In other words, the study found that the only method that had shown success in inhibiting an increase in pest resistance was one that advocates using less GM crops and abundant amounts of non-GM plants.

One of the study’s authors, Bruce Tabashnik of the University of Arizona, argued that the ability to delay GM resistance, no matter how short-lived, was a boon to the agriculture industry: “We always expect the pests to adapt,” he said. “However, if we can delay resistance from a few years to a few decades, that’s a big win.”

Liz O’Neil of the UK-based group GM Freeze, argued that delaying GM pest resistance was hardly a big win, as it was merely delaying the inevitable onset of complete GM ineffectiveness. In a press release, she stated:

This study confirms a very simple truth: if you try to outwit nature, it’s evolution that wins. We already know that if you grow herbicide tolerant GM crops you get herbicide resistant weeds. Now we have clear confirmation that the pattern repeats itself with insecticide-producing GM Bt crops.”


GM crops linked to long list of negative effects

Farmers hold signs as activists dressed as Bt brinjal eggplants, look on at a protest during Indian Environment Minister Jairam Ramesh's visit to attend a public hearing on the genetically modified eggplant crop at Central Research Institute for Dryland Agriculture in Hyderabad, India.(AP/Mahesh Kumar)

Farmers hold signs as activists dressed as Bt brinjal eggplants, look on at a protest during Indian Environment Minister Jairam Ramesh’s visit to attend a public hearing on the genetically modified eggplant crop at Central Research Institute for Dryland Agriculture in Hyderabad, India.(AP/Mahesh Kumar)

Bt crops have been a fixture in industrial agriculture for more than 20 years. Since their initial introduction in 1996, their use has become widespread, with more than 240 million acres of Bt crops — namely cotton, corn and soybeans — being planted in 2016 alone. Yet, ever since their introduction, Bt crops have been decidedly controversial for several reasons other than their link to a rapid increase in pest resistance, and consequent ineffectiveness.

For instance, the introduction of Bt crops in India – championed by the Gates Foundation — failed to bring any of the benefits farmers were promised, instead trapping many farmers in debt as their disappointing yields left them unable to pay for the expensive seeds and chemicals needed to cultivate GM plants. These burgeoning debt cycles have led to one of the largest suicide epidemics in the history of the world, with an estimated 300,000 Indian farmers having taken their own lives over the last 20 years.

In addition, the widespread use of GM crops has had dire consequences for other non-GM crops and the environment, due to the potential for cross-pollination contamination between GM and non-GM crops as well as the deleterious effects of GM crops and their associated agrochemicals on wildlife. Furthermore, consumption or use of GM crops has also been linked to a variety of human health issues.

However, it is ultimately the issue of pest resistance that suggests that GM crops are much more trouble than they are worth. The inevitability of pest resistance to GM crops, a fact acknowledged by the study’s authors, means that, over time, GM crops are bound to become much more ineffective than their less expensive and natural predecessors. With the long-term benefit to farmers being minimal, it is evident that continued use of GM crops primarily, if not exclusively, benefits the corporations that produce them.

Editor’s Note | The research paper referenced in this article, “Insect Resistance to Transgenic Crops: Second Decade Surge and Future Prospects,” was published on Oct. 10 in the October issue of Nature Biotechnology and is not yet available on online. DOI: 10.1038/nbt.3974

Top photo | The cotton bollworm caterpillar has evolved resistance to four Bt proteins produced by biotech crops. (Alex Yelich/University of Arizona)

The post Study: GM Crops, Touted For Pest Resistance, Rapidly Breed Resistant Pests appeared first on MintPress News.


Support this site

News Sources

Source Items
John Pilger 402
The Real News 327
Scrutinised Minds 17
Need To Know News 1037
FEE 2183
Marine Le Pen 143
Francois Asselineau 25
Opassande 50
HAX on 5July 220
Henrik Alexandersson 349
Mohamed Omar 189
Professors Blog 10
Arg Blatte Talar 37
Angry Foreigner 15
Fritte Fritzson 11
Teologiska rummet 28
Filosofiska rummet 55
Vetenskapsradion Historia 94
Snedtänkt (Kalle Lind) 153
Les Crises 1247
Richard Falk 73
Ian Sinclair 60
SpinWatch 34
Counter Currents 4099
Kafila 281
Gail Malone 27
Transnational Foundation 221
Rick Falkvinge 78
The Duran 5106
Vanessa Beeley 77
Nina Kouprianova 9
MintPress 3334
Paul Craig Roberts 820
News Junkie Post 42
Nomi Prins 19
Kurt Nimmo 191
Strategic Culture 2355
Sir Ken Robinson 15
Stephan Kinsella 48
Liberty Blitzkrieg 730
Sami Bedouin 60
Consortium News 1823
21 Century Wire 2486
Burning Blogger 253
Stephen Gowans 48
David D. Friedman 117
Anarchist Standard 16
The BRICS Post 1366
Tom Dispatch 326
Levant Report 17
The Saker 2726
The Barnes Review 433
John Friend 315
Psyche Truth 146
Jonathan Cook 122
New Eastern Outlook 2676
School Sucks Project 1087
Giza Death Star 1308
Andrew Gavin Marshall 15
Red Ice Radio 540
GMWatch 1475
Robert Faurisson 118
Espionage History Archive 33
Jay's Analysis 575
Le 4ème singe 80
Jacob Cohen 182
Agora Vox 7553
Cercle Des Volontaires 393
Panamza 1304
Fairewinds 102
Project Censored 546
Spy Culture 297
Conspiracy Archive 56
Crystal Clark 11
Timothy Kelly 332
PINAC 1472
The Conscious Resistance 449
Independent Science News 63
The Anti Media 4298
Positive News 820
Brandon Martinez 30
Steven Chovanec 50
Lionel 233
The Mind renewed 195
Natural Society 2391
Yanis Varoufakis 686
Tragedy & Hope 106
Dr. Tim Ball 53
Web of Debt 116
Porkins Policy Review 289
Conspiracy Watch 174
Eva Bartlett 511
Libyan War Truth 262
DeadLine Live 1889
Kevin Ryan 59
Aaron Franz 157
Traces of Reality 166
Revelations Radio News 108
Dr. Bruce Levine 95
Peter B Collins 1180
Faux Capitalism 203
Dissident Voice 8602
Climate Audit 211
Donna Laframboise 268
Judith Curry 1006
Geneva Business Insider 40
Media Monarchy 1709
Newsbud 2332
Syria Report 70
Human Rights Investigation 85
Intifada (Voice of Palestine) 1685
Down With Tyranny 8827
Laura Wells Solutions 15
Video Rebel's Blog 398
Revisionist Review 485
Aletho News 15786
ضد العولمة 27
Penny for your thoughts 2388
Northerntruthseeker 1830
كساريات 37
Color Revolutions and Geopolitics 27
Stop Nato 4498 Blog 2371 Original Content 5458
Corbett Report 1910
Stop Imperialism 491
Land Destroyer 1035
Webster Tarpley Website 784

Compiled Feeds

Public Lists

Title Visibility
Funny Public