Visit ArabTopics.com

Gergis and the PAGES2K Regional Average

The calculation of the PAGES2K regional average contains a very odd procedure that thus far has escaped commentary. The centerpiece of the PAGES2K program was the calculation of regional reconstructions in deg C anomalies. Having done these calculations, most readers would presume that their area weighted average (deg C) would be the weighted average of these regional reconstructions already expressed in deg C.

But this isn’t what they did. Instead, they first smoothed by taking 30-year averages, then converted the smoothed deg C regional reconstructions to SD units (basis 1200-1965) and took an average in SD units, converting the result back to deg C by “visual scaling”.

This procedure had a dramatic impact on the Gergis reconstruction. Expressed in deg C and as illustrated in the SI, it has a very mild blade. But, the peculiar PAGES2K procedure amplified the relatively small amplitude reconstruction into a monster blade with a 4 sigma closing value. Following the Arctic2K non-corrigendum correction, it is the largest blade in the reconstruction (and has the greatest area weight.)

I’ll show this procedure in today’s post.

.

PAGES2K Figure S2

First, here is PAGES2K Figure S2, showing the seven regional reconstructions (the Arctic obviously pre-corrections), The amplitude of the Australasian temperature change estimates (for whatever they are worth) are the smallest.

pages2k_fig_S2_regional-panel

Figure 1.   Excerpted from PAGES2K Figure S2.  Original caption:  Proxy temperature reconstructions for the seven regions of the PAGES 2k Network. Temperature anomalies are relative to the 1961-1990 CE reference period. Grey lines around expected-value estimates indicate uncertainty ranges as defined by each regional group (Supplemental Information Part II), namely: Antarctica, Australasia, North America pollen, and South America = ± 2SE; Asia = ± 2 RMSE; Europe = 95% confidence bands; Arctic = 90% confidence; North American trees = upper/lower 5% bootstrap bounds (these are inherently narrower than those of many other regions because they are reported at decadal and multi-decadal, rather than annual resolution). Instrumental temperatures are area-weighted mean annual temperatures over the reconstruction domains shown in Figure 1 from HadCRUT4 (ref. 9) land and ocean, rather than the target temperature series used in the regional reconstructions. This facilitates a uniform comparison among regions using a data series that extends to 2010. The actual reconstruction targets for each region are specified in Table 1. Reconstruction time series are listed in Supplementary Database S2.

Re-converting to SD Units

It’s hard to understand why the PAGES2K authors would convert series expressed in deg C back to SD units in order to calculate an area average, but that’s what they did.  The calculation is not described in detail, but is illustrated in their Figure 4b (and the nearly identical top panel of SI Figure 5.)  As I understand their procedure, they first calculated 30-year averages for each reconstruction (ending in 2000) ; then they converted the 30-year average series to SD units (basis 1200-1965) and then calculated an area average – shown in their Figure 4b (and SI Figure 5) as blue dots – see below.  This was then converted to temperature (see scale on right axis) by a super-sophisticated statistical methodology described in the caption as “scaled visually to match the standardized values over the instrumental period.”

 

 

 

figure4b_30year

 

Figure 2. Excerpt from PAGES2K Figure 4b (period 0-2000). Similar figure in PAGES2K SI Figure 5 top panel.  Original caption: Composite temperature reconstructions with climate forcings and previous hemisphere-scale reconstructions. … . b, Standardized 30-year-mean temperatures averaged across all seven continental-scale regions. Blue symbols are area-weighted averages using domain areas listed in Table 1, and bars show twenty-fifth and seventy-fifth unweighted percentiles to illustrate the variability among regions; open black boxes are unweighted medians. The red line is the 30-year-average annual global temperature from the HadCRUT4 (ref. 29) instrumental time series relative to 1961–1990, and scaled visually to match the standardized values over the instrumental period

 

Regional Panel in SD Units,

PAGES2K did not show the regional reconstructions in SD units – the form in which they contributed to the area-weighted average – an oversight which is remedied below. I’ve also used the PAGES2K-2014 Arctic version and added the average of 2014 versions. PAGES2K emphasized the long-term cooling trend up to the 20th century.    Squinting at these reconstructions, I’d be inclined to say that reversal of long-term cooling occurred somewhat earlier in their European and Asian reconstructions than their Arctic reconstruction and that no reversal is yet discernible in Antarctica, much the coldest area.  Curiously, the Gergis’ Australia reconstruction has, by a considerable margin,  the largest blade,  closing at over 4 sigma.   Thus, although it has a deceptively mild appearance when expressed in deg C (as in the main SI illustration excerpted above), it has a monster blade as used in the regional averaging.  This contribution is further exacerbated by the assignment of weights, as the Gergis’ Australasian reconstruction is assigned the largest area of any of the regions.

 

p2k-2014-regional

 

Figure 3. Seven regional reconstructions expressed in SD Units, together with area-weighted average (red).  The Gergis reconstruction (left column, bottom row) closes at over 4 sigma, The uncorrected Arctic reconstruction had a similarly large blade, but is more muted incorporating corrections to date.

Discussion 

This very large contribution from the Gergis reconstruction invites further examination, which I plan in a subsequent post.  The original Gergis reconstruction was discussed at length when it was released in 2012.  Their screening procedure was examined closely at CA, with Jean S demonstrating that, despite claims in their article that they had used detrended correlation to guard again spurious correlation, they had actually used non-detrended correlation.  This led to a non-retraction retraction: the article was disappeared without an obituary or retraction notice. The authors did not acknowledge CA, instead they claimed that they had “independently” discovered the problem at exactly the same time as the CA discussion.    Mann and Schmidt both wrote to Gergis supporting ex post screening. Gergis and coauthors (including Karoly) tried to persuade Journal of Climate that they should be allowed to change their description of methodology, but the journal asked them to show results using the described methodology as well and the article disappeared.

The  Gergis reconstruction in PAGES2K uses an almost identical network to the retracted article: of the 27 proxies in the original network, 20 are used in the P2K network: out are 1 tree ring, 2 ice core and 4 coral. The new network has 28 proxies: in are 2 tree ring, 1 speleo and 5 coral records.  As discussed in my original commentary, there are only two records in this network going back to the MWP – both tree ring records considered in Mann and Jones 2003 without much centennial variability.  As in the original reconstruction, the Gergis blade does not arise from multiple long records exhibiting modern values elevated relative to medieval values, but is more like a moustache stapled onto a shaft. I’ll revisit the revised Gergis reconstruction in a separate post.

Source: 
Climate Audit

Dear friends of this aggregator

  • Yes, I intentionally removed Newsbud from the aggregator on Mar 22.
  • Newsbud did not block the aggregator, although their editor blocked me on twitter after a comment I made to her
  • As far as I know, the only site that blocks this aggregator is Global Research. I have no idea why!!
  • Please stop recommending Newsbud and Global Research to be added to the aggregator.

Support this site

News Sources

Source Items
WWI Hidden History 51
Grayzone Project 299
Pass Blue 284
Dilyana Gaytandzhieva 16
John Pilger 421
The Real News 367
Scrutinised Minds 29
Need To Know News 2972
FEE 5046
Marine Le Pen 391
Francois Asselineau 25
Opassande 53
HAX on 5July 220
Henrik Alexandersson 1085
Mohamed Omar 403
Professors Blog 10
Arg Blatte Talar 40
Angry Foreigner 18
Fritte Fritzson 12
Teologiska rummet 32
Filosofiska rummet 127
Vetenskapsradion Historia 176
Snedtänkt (Kalle Lind) 239
Les Crises 3231
Richard Falk 191
Ian Sinclair 119
SpinWatch 61
Counter Currents 10883
Kafila 556
Gail Malone 42
Transnational Foundation 221
Rick Falkvinge 95
The Duran 10443
Vanessa Beeley 174
Nina Kouprianova 9
MintPress 5808
Paul Craig Roberts 2179
News Junkie Post 59
Nomi Prins 27
Kurt Nimmo 191
Strategic Culture 5507
Sir Ken Robinson 25
Stephan Kinsella 107
Liberty Blitzkrieg 870
Sami Bedouin 65
Consortium News 2685
21 Century Wire 3838
Burning Blogger 324
Stephen Gowans 97
David D. Friedman 157
Anarchist Standard 16
The BRICS Post 1529
Tom Dispatch 575
Levant Report 18
The Saker 4758
The Barnes Review 556
John Friend 509
Psyche Truth 160
Jonathan Cook 162
New Eastern Outlook 4510
School Sucks Project 1789
Giza Death Star 2042
Andrew Gavin Marshall 15
Red Ice Radio 642
GMWatch 2466
Robert Faurisson 150
Espionage History Archive 35
Jay's Analysis 1082
Le 4ème singe 90
Jacob Cohen 214
Agora Vox 17566
Cercle Des Volontaires 445
Panamza 2374
Fairewinds 118
Project Censored 1069
Spy Culture 591
Conspiracy Archive 81
Crystal Clark 11
Timothy Kelly 607
PINAC 1482
The Conscious Resistance 924
Independent Science News 84
The Anti Media 6850
Positive News 820
Brandon Martinez 30
Steven Chovanec 61
Lionel 305
The Mind renewed 452
Natural Society 2621
Yanis Varoufakis 1054
Tragedy & Hope 122
Dr. Tim Ball 114
Web of Debt 158
Porkins Policy Review 446
Conspiracy Watch 174
Eva Bartlett 626
Libyan War Truth 352
DeadLine Live 1916
Kevin Ryan 64
BSNEWS 2101
Aaron Franz 254
Traces of Reality 166
Revelations Radio News 121
Dr. Bruce Levine 153
Peter B Collins 1685
Faux Capitalism 205
Dissident Voice 11362
Climate Audit 226
Donna Laframboise 478
Judith Curry 1160
Geneva Business Insider 40
Media Monarchy 2556
Syria Report 78
Human Rights Investigation 93
Intifada (Voice of Palestine) 1685
Down With Tyranny 12806
Laura Wells Solutions 46
Video Rebel's Blog 452
Revisionist Review 485
Aletho News 21799
ضد العولمة 27
Penny for your thoughts 3188
Northerntruthseeker 2583
كساريات 37
Color Revolutions and Geopolitics 27
Stop Nato 4803
AntiWar.com Blog 3286
AntiWar.com Original Content 7342
Corbett Report 2509
Stop Imperialism 491
Land Destroyer 1252
Webster Tarpley Website 1137

Compiled Feeds

Public Lists

Title Visibility
Funny Public