EXCLUSIVE: After Bundy Trial’s Celebrated Dismissal, Fate of Remaining Defendants, Land Rights Issues Still in Question

By Mark Anderson
21st Century Wire

“I went into that place a free man and I intended to leave it as a free man.”

That’s what lifelong Nevada rancher Cliven Bundy stated to this writer upon being released from imprisonment along with his sons Ryan and Ammon, and co-defendant Ryan Payne—due to the dismissal of the charges against them in U.S. District Court in Las Vegas.

The elder Bundy, jubilant over the fact that his ordeal and that of his family and supporters is essentially over, added with a hearty laugh that he was a bit jaded from giving nonstop press interviews in the wake of federal Judge Gloria Navarro’s Jan. 8 ruling to approve Ryan Payne’s motion to dismiss the case.

Cliven, a constitutionalist whose family is well-versed in the nation’s charter, added that, under Article III, judges can hold office only during periods of good behavior.  “Good behavior is when our judges are in tune with the Constitution. When you’ve got judges like I had in my case—abridging the Constitution—nobody holds them accountable,” he also told this writer, for an earlier American Free Press story.

What mainly prompted Judge Navarro to dismiss this latest trial—with prejudice—was that federal agents and prosecutors withheld key evidence from the defense. “With prejudice,” according to longtime Bundy-trial observer and legal expert Roger Roots, J.D., Ph.D., means the government would have to seek a new indictment to retry these defendants, which would be double-jeopardy and therefore is highly unlikely to happen. While a government appeal of the dismissal cannot be absolutely ruled out, it seems quite remote at this juncture.

Federal prosecutors had feverishly tried to nail the defendants—19 of them initially indicted under 16 counts—for resisting and protesting an attempted but failed impoundment of Cliven’s cattle by armed Bureau of Land Management and FBI agents in the “Bunkerville standoff” in Clark County, Nevada in April of 2014. The impoundment attempt made world headlines as scores of supporters, some of whom were armed in the open-carry state, showed up that spring from across the nation and stood with the Bundys. No shots were fired by either side and the feds eventually backed down.


Not that things have gone well for the defense across the board. Defendant Gregory Burleson of Arizona did get 68 years and co-defendant Todd Engel, of Idaho, whose sentencing is pending, conceivably could get up to 18 years if the government gets its way. Burleson was even wheelchair-bound and reportedly losing his eyesight when sentenced.

Pete Santilli, who until recently was a co-defendant in Cliven’s trial, was given a plea agreement and reportedly has returned to Ohio to resume his work as an internet radio host, amid certain court-ordered conditions. Although he’ll likely get credit for jail-time served, he’s supposed to be sentenced this spring.


Officially, there’s another trial pending involving defendants Mel and Dave Bundy (two more of Cliven’s sons), Joseph O’Shaughnessy and Jason Woods. But Roots understands a dismissal is being sought.

Moreover, defendants Blaine Cooper, Eric Parker and O. Scott Drexler copped pleas and are awaiting spring sentencings. Additional defendants who took plea agreements are Jerry DeLemus, Brian Cavalier and Micah McGuire.

Jim Lambley, owner of KSDZ-FM “The Twister,” in Nebraska, has been reporting on this case the most of any single licensed broadcast-media outlet. He agreed with this writer’s observation that it appears the government committed an especially grave miscarriage of justice in the way it handled the now-legendary series of “Bundy” show trials starting in February 2017 to the present.

“The government needs to write some checks because it stole the lives of these people for two years,” Lambley commented, regarding how prosecutors dragged out this affair over nearly two years based on rather vague and redundant conspiracy, obstruction and weapons charges, among other charges, that ultimately proved weak.

The dismissal of the trial of Cliven, Ammon and the two Ryans followed Judge Navarro’s Dec. 20, 2017, decision to declare a mistrial. That alone in the eyes of many was a stunning development in the saga of the elder Nevada rancher whose unwavering devotion to principle, like that of his sons and supporters, represents in the minds of many a repudiation of the arbitrary exercise of federal power, particularly heavy-handed federal control over vast tracts of land in the American West, where tortoises and other wildlife seem to have rights akin to those of humans.


Even the mainstream publication Newsweek reported in May 2014: “In 1994, [the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service] acknowledged in its Desert Tortoise Recovery Plan that the ‘extremely controversial’ question of whether cattle harmed tortoise populations was not settled. In 2002, the U.S. Geological Survey said in a report that the evidence for the harm done by cattle was ‘not overwhelming.’ William Boarman, the biologist who wrote the report, said he was not aware of subsequent studies showing a strong link.”

And as Americans for Limited Government recently reported in the just-released Jan. 15-22 edition of American Free Press: “The desert tortoise was abundant decades ago when the cattle population was much [greater] and the range was overgrazed. Ironically, as BLM restrictions on cattle grazing grew stricter, the desert tortoise population declined. The evidence that cattle are detrimental to the desert tortoise was so weak that two judges ruled in favor of [Cliven] Bundy’s neighbors who had sued to stop the BLM’s efforts to drive their cattle off the range. But the BLM under the Clinton administration . . . tightened regulations on the ranchers and ultimately succeeded in removing their cattle from the range. Incredibly, while the federal government continues to try to remove the relatively few remaining cattle from Clark County, it continues to protect the common raven—which is not at all endangered—even though it regularly devours young tortoises.”

The April 2014 impoundment attempt was said to have been ordered over Cliven not paying grazing fees, but pernicious wildlife regulations on that public land clearly played a role. At any rate, Cliven maintains that federal jurisdiction was never established over Clark County in the area’s unique history. Writing on in an article that provides considerable additional background information on the overall Bundy affair, Roots recalled:

In 2013 the federal Bureau of Land Management (BLM) obtained federal court orders authorizing the agency to “seize and remove to impound” hundreds of Cliven Bundy’s cattle on the public ranges around Bunkerville, Nevada.  The agency interpreted these court orders broadly, and descended on the area in April 2014 with some 200 body-armor-wearing agents, semiautomatic weapons, sniper teams, undercover informants, and surveillance cameras aimed at the Bundy residence.

The BLM brought more than corrals and horse trailers.  They brought backhoes, dump trucks and earth-moving equipment to tear up water lines and other infrastructure that had been built by Bundy and his ancestors over decades.  Defying county officials, the federal officers chose calving season—the very time when cows and newborn calves are most physically weak and vulnerable—to execute the court orders.  They orchestrated a para-militarized roundup operation using helicopters to terrify the cattle into stampeding to the point of exhaustion in extreme heat. At least 40 cows either died from the ordeal or were shot by BLM employees and contractors.


Throughout several trials and numerous hearings concerning the Bundy case, Judge Navarro was believed to be unsympathetic to the defendants, yet when she dismissed Cliven and company’s trial, she reiterated that prosecutors willfully withheld exculpatory evidence from defense lawyers. That’s what tipped the scales. She referred to it as “flagrant prosecutorial misconduct” while also declaring: “The court finds that the universal sense of justice has been violated,” inferring that the government’s misdeeds in this case were legion.

That’s evidently true, and those misdeeds transcended the courtroom. Marooning the defendants in jail for so long, of course, denied them a fair and speedy trial as the Constitution requires. And Ammon and Ryan were grossly humiliated when they were subjected to deep-cavity strip searches every time they were transferred from their jail cells to the U.S. District Court. The government even imposed solitary confinement at times. Given the conduct of their jailers, you’d think that Cliven and company already had been convicted and sentenced to languish in some surreal dungeon.

Asked if Cliven, his sons and the others had indeed been political prisoners as Cliven claimed—given that they were jailed for what they believe and who they are—Roots replied, “If they had been left-wingers they would never have been looking at such ridiculous charges. The thing about Cliven and the others is that they provided real resistance with real constitutional principles.”

Crucial remaining matters also include the Las Vegas Review Journal’s motion to try and force the federal government to open all its files. If the motion succeeds, it could reveal whether illegal secret court hearings were held and, among many other things, provide more information on federal snipers and surveillance cameras in the vicinity of the standoff and the Bundy homestead—despite denials by the prosecution about such things.

Speaking to this writer, Cliven summarized: “They tried to ruin my ranch, my heritage and my posterity. But we’re in the cattle business and we intend to stay there. We’ve always been producers, producing great beef for America.”


See more of Mark Anderson’s articles at and at www.

READ MORE BUNDY RANCH NEWS AT: 21st Century Wire Bundy Ranch Files


21 Century Wire

Support this site

News Sources

Source Items
The Real News 240
Scrutinised Minds 16
Need To Know News 838
FEE 1910
Marine Le Pen 92
Francois Asselineau 25
Opassande 50
HAX on 5July 220
Henrik Alexandersson 347
Mohamed Omar 170
Professors Blog 10
Arg Blatte Talar 36
Angry Foreigner 14
Fritte Fritzson 11
Teologiska rummet 28
Filosofiska rummet 49
Vetenskapsradion Historia 65
Snedtänkt (Kalle Lind) 144
Les Crises 1057
Richard Falk 64
Ian Sinclair 54
SpinWatch 31
Counter Currents 3403
Kafila 256
Gail Malone 24
Transnational Foundation 221
Rick Falkvinge 74
The Duran 4700
Vanessa Beeley 65
Nina Kouprianova 9
MintPress 3014
Paul Craig Roberts 712
News Junkie Post 40
Nomi Prins 17
Kurt Nimmo 191
Strategic Culture 2069
Sir Ken Robinson 13
Stephan Kinsella 39
Liberty Blitzkrieg 703
Sami Bedouin 60
Consortium News 1701
21 Century Wire 2353
Burning Blogger 243
Stephen Gowans 47
David D. Friedman 111
Anarchist Standard 16
The BRICS Post 1295
Tom Dispatch 300
Levant Report 17
The Saker 2553
The Barnes Review 422
John Friend 305
Psyche Truth 146
Jonathan Cook 122
New Eastern Outlook 2500
School Sucks Project 1074
Giza Death Star 1219
Andrew Gavin Marshall 15
Red Ice Radio 528
GMWatch 1380
Robert Faurisson 113
Espionage History Archive 33
Jay's Analysis 534
Le 4ème singe 67
Jacob Cohen 171
Agora Vox 6588
Cercle Des Volontaires 376
Panamza 1211
Fairewinds 98
Project Censored 515
Spy Culture 281
Conspiracy Archive 56
Crystal Clark 11
Timothy Kelly 314
PINAC 1455
The Conscious Resistance 430
Independent Science News 60
The Anti Media 3935
Positive News 793
Brandon Martinez 30
Steven Chovanec 47
Lionel 224
The Mind renewed 191
Natural Society 2391
Yanis Varoufakis 648
Tragedy & Hope 106
Dr. Tim Ball 52
Web of Debt 113
Porkins Policy Review 272
Conspiracy Watch 174
Eva Bartlett 494
Libyan War Truth 254
DeadLine Live 1882
Kevin Ryan 57
Aaron Franz 153
Traces of Reality 166
Revelations Radio News 102
Dr. Bruce Levine 91
Peter B Collins 1127
Faux Capitalism 203
Dissident Voice 8353
Climate Audit 207
Donna Laframboise 240
Judith Curry 987
Geneva Business Insider 40
Media Monarchy 1627
Newsbud 2258
Syria Report 70
Human Rights Investigation 85
Intifada (Voice of Palestine) 1685
Down With Tyranny 8449
Laura Wells Solutions 15
Video Rebel's Blog 397
Revisionist Review 474
Aletho News 15196
ضد العولمة 27
Penny for your thoughts 2306
Northerntruthseeker 1757
كساريات 37
Color Revolutions and Geopolitics 27
Stop Nato 4474 Blog 2285 Original Content 5272
Corbett Report 1855
Stop Imperialism 491
Land Destroyer 1016
Webster Tarpley Website 739

Compiled Feeds

Public Lists

Title Visibility
Funny Public